General Discussion on the Approach as a Whole

Feedback from Hazel Henderson (received by e-mail on August 10th 2006 and posted here upon request):

"My congratulations to Dr. Michael Ben-Eli for a comprehensive document. My overall comment is that of course, the document is "Western" and could use some of the multi-cultural approaches of the 16 Principles of the Earth Charter (www.earthcharter.org )".

"Regarding the Intro and Definition of Sustainability, I would substitute "stewarding" for the sexist term "husbanding" which might turn off half your audience. Also, the term "wealth" needs defining up front, because so many people are brainwashed to equate wealth with money (worthless pieces of paper or blips on computer screens)".

"I worry about dropping inter-generational equity from the definition of sustainability -- even though the needs of future generations are indeterminate, so is the carrying capacity of interpenetrating ecosystems from global to local. The criterion of measurability has lead to many "fallacies of mis-placed concreteness" to quote Alfred North Whitehead."

For more information about Hazel Henderson go to:http://www.hazelhenderson.com/

Inter-Generational Equity

No need to drop the concept of inter-generation equity entirely. It obviously articulates an idea that is, in principle, correct. Important to accept, however, that as it stands, it does not offer a rigorous enough definition and, should, therfore, at least be augmented.

The very ease by which it was adopted by the development community attest to the fact, that it could receive enough different specific interpretations, to let everybody off the hook...

Fuller's Definition of Wealth

Bucky Fuller's definition should suffice: "Wealth is our organized capability to cope effectively with the environment in sustaining our healthy regeneration and decreasing both the physical and metaphysical restrictions of the forward days of our lives." (From "Operating Manual for Spaceship Earth" http://www.bfi.org/?q=node/416)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.